Methodology

How we test, score and rank email tools.

Transparent, repeatable, and never influenced by commercial relationships.

1. We sign up

Every tool we review, we use. Free trial first, paid plan if needed.

2. We build a real campaign

List import, segmentation, automation, broadcast, A/B test. Apples-to-apples.

3. We measure deliverability

We send to a panel of real seed inboxes and blend in real-customer engagement data from Email Heatmaps users — a unique edge.

4. We score across 8 axes

UX, automation depth, deliverability, segmentation, reporting, integrations, support, pricing transparency.

5. We re-test annually

Pricing and features shift. So do our scores.

6. We disclose every link

Affiliate or not — flagged on the page and in the footer.

Our deliverability advantage

Most review sites rely solely on seed-list inboxes — a methodology widely criticised for poor real-world correlation. We complement seed testing with real engagement data from Email Heatmaps customer campaigns (anonymised, aggregated). That gives us a far better picture of how each ESP actually performs in the wild.

Affiliate disclosure

We earn affiliate commissions on some links — at no extra cost to you. Affiliate status never influences scoring. We're happy to recommend a tool we earn nothing from if it's the right one.

Spotted a mistake?

Tell us. [email protected] — we'll fix it.